Is Your Interview Losing You the Best Senior Candidates?

Last week I wrote for candidates about what to do when the interviewer isn’t ready. This piece is for the other side of the table, because the stories behind it deserve the attention of every hiring manager, HR leader and executive who sits on an interview panel.

Over the last few months, a number of my executive-level clients have described interviews that didn’t quite do them, or the organisation, justice. In some, the interviewer had clearly been pulled in at the last minute and was reading the CV for the first time; in others, the questions were so general that the conversation never really got going. Each of them said they had to work hard to give the interviewer what they knew the interviewer needed to hear, and a couple decided afterwards that the role wasn’t for them.

None of this is a criticism of the people doing the interviewing. Senior leaders are stretched, interviews land in already overloaded diaries, and very few have ever been trained to interview well. I’ve sat on every side of this process, as a headhunter, in recruitment at Goldman Sachs and Merrill Lynch, and now with my Hanover Search hat on as well as coaching candidates every week, and what I’ve seen consistently is that the best senior candidates usually have other options. For them, the interview is their first real experience of you, your leadership and your organisation, so you have to get it right.

The stakes are high on both sides. Kevin Kelly, then chief executive of Heidrick & Struggles, told the Financial Times that across 20,000 of the firm’s searches, around 40% of senior executives hired were pushed out, failed or quit within 18 months. The interview is where that risk is either reduced or locked in, and yet it is often the least designed part of the whole process. The organisations that hire well at senior level tend to do six things.

  1. Agree what you’re hiring for, and why now

    The strongest hiring processes start long before the first interview, with a shared view of why the role exists now and what the person needs to deliver in their first year. Is it a growth hire, a turnaround, a succession plan or the replacement for someone who didn’t work out? Each one calls for a different profile. When the panel hasn’t agreed which it is, interviewers compare candidates with each other and with their own instincts, and strong people get lost in the gap.

    Write it down: the three or four outcomes that will define success, the capabilities those outcomes demand, and the risks the board is most concerned about. Any scoring framework then becomes a record of a conversation the panel has already had, which is far more useful than a form filled in after the event.

  2. Design the process before you write the questions

    During my years in investment banking recruitment, a senior candidate could easily meet ten people before an offer was made. Much of my role was persuading those ten interviewers, each with a demanding day job, to agree a structure and a plan before they met anyone. Left to instinct, many would fall back on some version of what was known as the aeroplane test: would I be happy sitting next to this person on a long-haul flight? Chemistry has its place, yet on its own it tends to favour people who remind us of ourselves, and it says very little about how someone will actually perform in the role.

    More interviews don’t necessarily mean better decisions either. When Google’s people analytics team looked back at five years of its own interview data, it found that four interviews predicted the hiring outcome with around 86% accuracy, and following those four, each additional interview added very little. What makes the difference is giving every interviewer a distinct part of the assessment, so for example, the CEO explores strategic fit, the CFO tests commercial grip and the HR Director probes leadership and culture, instead of all of them circling the same ground.

  3. Structure the conversation, and leave room to probe

    Of all the ways organisations assess people, structured interviews are among the most reliable. A major 2022 review of selection research by Paul Sackett ranked them as the strongest single predictor of job performance. Structure here means asking every candidate the same core questions, anchored to the outcomes you agreed, so that you are comparing like with like, while leaving plenty of room for the follow-up questions where the real insight sits.

    At senior level, generic competency questions tend to produce polished, rehearsed answers. After all, every senior candidate has a good STAR story about a difficult stakeholder. The value comes from the second and third questions: what did you notice first, what options did you weigh, what risk did you choose to carry, and what would you do differently now? Better still, bring the conversation into your own business. Describe a real challenge the incoming leader will face, whether that’s integrating an acquisition, rebuilding a team or a regulatory review on the horizon, and ask how they would approach their first ninety days.

  4. Make it a conversation between peers, and sell the opportunity

    Senior candidates give their best when the interview feels like a conversation between peers, and their most guarded answers when it feels like an interrogation. Explain the format, who is on the panel and why, and how the process will run from here, then leave real time for their questions. The best candidates are doing their own due diligence on your board, your strategy and your culture, and the quality of their questions will often tell you as much as anything else.

    The majority of the executive candidates we work with are already in good roles, or are being courted elsewhere at the same time, so every interviewer is also an ambassador. The strongest candidates are weighing up a decision as significant as yours, and they will want a candid account of why the role exists, what the business needs from it and what the first year will really demand. Be open about the difficult parts, because senior candidates can usually tell when a challenge is being glossed over, and candour builds trust faster than any pitch. Keep the story consistent, too. If the CEO, the HR Director and the hiring manager each describe a slightly different role, the candidate will reasonably wonder whether anyone has agreed what the job is.

  5. Hold the line on the fundamentals

    None of the above works if the fundamentals slip, and from the candidates we speak to every week, we know they often do. The interviewer who opens the CV for the first time as the candidate sits down, the panel member who joins late and leaves early, the question that makes it obvious nobody has read the headhunter’s notes: each of these tells a senior candidate something about how the organisation operates. None of it is rocket science. Read the CV properly and annotate it with the follow-up questions this particular career raises. The core questions stay the same for every candidate, but where you probe will differ, because a CFO with a turnaround background and one who has spent fifteen years in a stable listed business will take you down very different paths. Protect the time, arrive on schedule and know who else on the panel is covering what. At this level, the way you run the interview is part of the offer.

  6. Decide well, and close the loop quickly

    How a panel reaches its decision deserves as much care as the interviews themselves. Crucially, ask each interviewer to score against the agreed outcomes independently before the debrief, so the view of the most senior or loudest person in the room doesn’t shape everyone else’s. Then debrief while the conversations are fresh and make the decision promptly.

    The end of the process is where good intentions most often slip. I hear from so many candidates who have been left waiting for weeks after a final interview, and Greenhouse’s 2024 research found that six in ten UK job seekers had been ghosted after an interview. When feedback does arrive, it often says something like “there wasn’t much between the candidates” or “we really liked you”, which no one can act on. Senior networks are smaller than most organisations assume, headhunters talk to candidates and candidates talk to each other, and the runner-up in this process may well be the person you want for the next role. How you treated them this time will decide whether they take your call and what they say about you to the market.

The interview is your pitch too

When a strong candidate walks away from an interview feeling they had to run it themselves, the cost goes well beyond an hour in the diary. The organisation may have lost the person best placed to do the job, and given them a story to tell every headhunter and peer they speak to afterwards. Senior hires carry real risk, and the organisations that manage it best treat the interview as their pitch as much as the candidate’s. It shows in the calibre of people who accept their offers.

At Hanover Talent Solutions we work on both sides of the table. For organisations, our executive coaching and leadership development programmes help leaders and hiring teams build the skills to attract, assess and secure the best senior talent. For individuals, our executive interview coaching helps senior candidates walk into every interview, however well or badly it is run, with their agenda set and their value ready to land. If either would help you or your leadership team, please get in touch with me or the team to talk it through.

Victoria McLean is CEO and founder of Hanover Talent Solutions and City CV, part of the Hanover Search Group, where she holds a board role. A former headhunter, recruitment lead at Goldman Sachs and Merrill Lynch, and a Non-Executive Director, she has spent 30 years helping organisations and senior leaders through hiring, transition and leadership development.